A 3-3 Vote in Washington Puts a Question Mark Over Southern Hemisphere Lamb

Published in Industry Insights

A 3-3 Vote in Washington Puts a Question Mark Over Southern Hemisphere Lamb

The US International Trade Commission split 3-3 on 13 November in its lamb safeguard case, sending it to a remedy phase, and our view is that the real effect for the global lamb trade is a planning question about where Australian and New Zealand lamb goes in 2027.

Profile picture of Martina Osmak

Martina Osmak

Director of Marketing

MeatBorsa's take

This section is our reading of the news, not reported fact. The confirmed figures and decisions follow further down.

Nothing changed for lamb on the water this week. Chilled and frozen lamb from Australia and New Zealand is still entering the US on the same terms as before the vote. What changed is the planning horizon. The US case on lamb imports has now moved into a remedy phase, and the final decision belongs to the US President after 11 January 2027. We do not try to guess that decision. What we can do is describe what the open question means for the market.

We think the main effect, for now, is uncertainty on US-bound volume for 2027. Australia supplies about three quarters of US lamb imports, and the US produces only around 60,000 tonnes of sheepmeat a year. That makes the US a large and import-dependent outlet for Southern Hemisphere lamb. While the outcome is open, every exporter selling into that outlet carries a question about how much it can place there next year, and at what return.

For Europe, the UK, the Middle East and China, the question is indirect but real. If any US measure did reduce the amount of lamb the US takes, that lamb would have to find buyers elsewhere. Southern Hemisphere exporters would then compete harder in the other markets they already serve. If no measure follows, none of this happens and the trade carries on as it is. Either way, we expect the next two months to be about watching US shipments and contract timing rather than prices.

What we assume, and why we could be wrong

  • We assume the US is one of the better-paying outlets for lamb cuts, so exporters would only move volume elsewhere at a lower return. If other markets are paying close to US levels, any redirection would be smaller and quieter than we describe.
  • We assume US importers may bring some purchases forward while the terms for 2027 are unclear. If US demand stays steady instead, export data will show no early surge.
  • We assume other markets could only absorb extra lamb at lower prices. If demand in Asia or the Middle East is strong enough, redirected lamb could be absorbed without much effect on European or UK prices.
  • We could be wrong about the size of the effect altogether. A remedy can take very different forms, from duties to quotas to adjustment help for US producers, and a small measure may barely change trade flows.

What happened

On 13 November 2026, the US International Trade Commission (USITC) announced an equally divided vote in its global safeguard investigation on lamb meat. Three commissioners, Chairman Brett W. Doyle and Commissioners Jason E. Kearns and Bart Thanhauser, found that rising imports are a substantial cause of serious injury to the US lamb industry. Commissioners Peter-Anthony Pappas, David Foley Jr. and Samuel T. Negatu found that they are not.

Under US trade law, a tied vote moves the case to the remedy phase. The investigation covers fresh, chilled and frozen lamb from all origins. It was opened on 13 July 2026 under section 202 of the Trade Act of 1974, at the request of the US Trade Representative. Australian farm media report that the request followed pressure from the American Sheep Industry Association.

The commissioners who voted in favour also made country findings for US free trade partners. They found that imports from Australia, on its own, are a substantial cause of serious injury. They found that imports from Canada, Mexico and other free trade partners are not. New Zealand does not have a free trade agreement with the US, so it falls under the global case.

The key dates and figures:

  • 1 December 2026: USITC public hearing on remedies.
  • 11 January 2027: deadline for the USITC report to the President. Because the vote was tied, both groups of commissioners send their views.
  • Possible remedies: a higher duty, a quota, a tariff-rate quota, adjustment assistance, or a mix. A measure can last up to four years at first and up to eight years in total.
  • About 75%: Australia's share of US lamb imports, according to Farm Online.

How each side sees it

The two positions are far apart. The case was brought because US sheep producers argue that imports are hurting their industry, and three commissioners agreed.

Exporting countries reject this. New Zealand's Trade Minister Todd McClay said, as reported by Newstalk ZB, that New Zealand lamb does not harm US producers and helps meet growing consumer demand in the US. He has directed officials to travel to Washington for the remedy hearing.

Farm Online, writing from Australia, set out the long-term numbers behind the exporters' argument. US sheepmeat production fell from about 155,000 tonnes in 1989 to around 60,000 tonnes. Between 1990 and 2010, US output dropped by nearly 78,000 tonnes while Australian lamb imports rose by about 23,400 tonnes. The same outlet notes that Americans eat only about 500 grams of sheepmeat per person per year, and that the US applied safeguard measures to Australian and New Zealand lamb once before, in 1999.

What we are watching next

  • The 1 December remedy hearing, and which types of remedy are put forward.
  • Australian and New Zealand export data for December and January, to see whether US-bound shipments rise early.
  • Lamb prices in the UK and EU in early 2027, as a sign of whether Southern Hemisphere exporters are competing harder in other markets.
  • A question worth asking your suppliers: how much of their lamb programme is currently planned for the US market, and how they would handle 2027 contracts if the terms changed.

Sources

USITC Reaches Equally Divided Determination in Lamb Meat Global Safeguard Investigation - US International Trade Commission

Lamb Meat Global Safeguard Investigation, Inv. No. TA-201-80 - US International Trade Commission

US trade panel deadlocked on Australian lamb imports, leaving threat alive - Farm Online

The US International Trade Commission is progressing its investigation of our lamb exports - Newstalk ZB / NZCity

A 3-3 Vote in Washington Puts a Question Mark Over Southern Hemisphere Lamb | MeatBorsa News